Costco Wholesale Corporation (NASDAQ: COST) continues to be a retail juggernaut, driven by its bulk-buying, bargain-hunting customer base. Following a record-breaking 2024 for sales and earnings, the discount retailer is leveraging a resilient economic landscape and a strong e-commerce strategy to sustain its momentum into 2025. With the stock trading at an all-time high after a 47% gain over the past year, investors are asking whether now is the time to buy, sell, or hold.
The Case to Buy or Hold Costco Stock
1. Strong Membership Model and Customer Loyalty
Costco’s members-only concept remains a massive draw for consumers, with 139 million cardholders worldwide. The company’s loyal customer base appreciates access to low prices across a wide range of products, from everyday essentials to high-ticket items like electronics and furniture. Additional perks, such as discounted gasoline, travel services, and in-store pharmacy benefits, make the annual membership fee worthwhile for many consumers.
Costco’s high membership renewal rates underscore its operating strength. This membership-driven revenue model provides a steady, predictable income stream and helps insulate the company from broader retail market fluctuations.
2. Impressive Sales Growth
In January 2025, Costco reported net sales growth of 9.2% year-over-year. Comparable store sales, excluding changes in gasoline prices and foreign exchange, rose 9.8%. This strong performance highlights Costco’s continued ability to attract customers despite an uncertain economic environment.
3. E-Commerce Expansion
Costco’s e-commerce business has become a critical growth driver. Comparable online sales increased 13.6% year-over-year in January, showcasing the company's ability to leverage its logistics infrastructure and diversify its merchandise mix for a broader online consumer market.
4. Expansion and Revenue Forecasts
Wall Street estimates suggest Costco is on track for a 7% revenue increase in 2025 and 2026. The company’s decision to raise membership fees in the U.S. and Canada is expected to bolster top-line growth and profitability. Additionally, plans to open 20 new warehouses in fiscal 2025 will likely attract new memberships.
Analysts project Costco’s earnings per share (EPS) to climb at a 10% annual rate over the next two years, signaling continued profitability growth.
The Case to Sell Costco Stock
1. Expensive Valuation
Despite Costco’s strong fundamentals, the stock currently trades at 58 times its projected 2025 EPS—a significant premium compared to peers such as Walmart and Amazon, which have forward P/E ratios closer to 37.
This elevated valuation reflects investor confidence in Costco’s membership-based model and operational consistency. However, it raises concerns about limited upside potential and vulnerability to market corrections.
2. Macro Risks and Competitive Pressures
Costco faces exposure to broader macroeconomic conditions. Proposed trade tariffs could disrupt supply chains or increase operational costs, potentially impacting margins.
Moreover, although Costco has maintained a competitive edge, it continues to face challenges from traditional retailers and online giants, particularly as e-commerce competition intensifies.
3. High Expectations
The market’s high expectations for Costco leave little room for underperformance. Any slowdown in membership growth or difficulties achieving financial targets could trigger a negative response from investors.
Conclusion: Buy, Sell, or Hold?
Given Costco’s strong fundamentals and growth prospects, current shareholders have a compelling case to hold their positions. The company’s resilient business model, loyal customer base, and e-commerce expansion provide a solid foundation for continued success.
However, potential buyers may find the current valuation too steep to justify initiating a position with conviction. Investors should remain cautious and consider waiting for a market correction that could present a more attractive entry point.
Costco remains a stock to watch closely. Its proven ability to navigate economic challenges and capitalize on growth opportunities underscores its long-term investment appeal—just not necessarily at today’s lofty price levels.
Comments